It’s a late evening at the firehouse in 2024. After decades of service, this is it, your career is finally over, and this is your last day on the job. Over coffee in the station kitchen, you joke about finally taking that fishing trip and cashing those Social Security checks you earned from your side gig. But when you finally check your Social Security statement, you feel like you got hit by a two-and-a-half-inch hose stream. All those years paying into Social Security from your side job – and your expected benefit is zero. The culprit? An obscure rule called the Windfall Elimination Provision (WEP).
You wouldn’t have been alone. Many firefighters have side hustles or second careers where they paid into Social Security, only to find out later that a rule like WEP could wipe out a big chunk of their benefits. A lot of good firefighters felt burned by these unfair rules.
The good news? As of January 5, 2025, that raw deal is history. The unfair provisions that hosed Social Security – WEP (and its cousin, the Government Pension Offset or GPO) – have been fully repealed. This is huge news for firefighters and other public servants. Let’s break down what WEP and GPO were, why their repeal matters, and what you should do now to make the most of this change.
What Were WEP and GPO?
The Windfall Elimination Provision (WEP) and Government Pension Offset (GPO) were two rules that hit firefighters’ Social Security benefits hard.
WEP (Windfall Elimination Provision)
This rule cut your Social Security check if you had a pension from non-Social Security-covered work (like most firefighting jobs) plus Social Security credits from other work. If you worked construction before joining the department or picked up side jobs where you paid Social Security taxes, WEP would slash your earned Social Security benefits. A $1,000 monthly Social Security check could drop by hundreds – money you earned but couldn’t collect.
GPO (Government Pension Offset)
This one targeted spousal and survivor benefits. If you collected a government pension and hadn’t paid into Social Security, GPO would cut your spouse’s Social Security benefit by 2/3 of your pension amount. Translation: your spouse’s Social Security could vanish entirely. This hit especially hard when a firefighter passed away, leaving their spouse with severely reduced benefits despite years of their partner’s Social Security contributions.
Bottom line: These provisions penalized firefighters and their families for having both a pension and Social Security credits, effectively reducing benefits they’d rightfully earned through their service and work.
Why Was It a Problem for Firefighters?
To put it bluntly, WEP and GPO felt like a punishment for public servants. Here’s why these provisions were a real thorn in the side for firefighters:
You Paid In, But Got Less Out
Firefighters are no strangers to working second jobs – side hustles, part-time gigs on off days, or even entire previous careers before joining the fire service. That’s a lot of extra midnight oil burned and weekends sacrificed, and you paid Social Security taxes on those earnings just like everyone else. But along came WEP, and suddenly, your Social Security benefit from those jobs was chopped down. It didn’t matter that you earned it dollar by dollar – WEP treated you as if you were getting an unearned “bonus.” In reality, it was your money to begin with!
Blindsiding Your Plans
One of the worst parts was the surprise factor. Plenty of firefighters only learned about WEP/GPO as they approached retirement. It’s not exactly something HR highlights on your first day. So there you are, thinking you did everything right – paid into your pension, paid into Social Security from other work, maybe even planned out a budget – and then you get hit with, “Oh, by the way, you won’t get that $800 a month you expected.” For a family, that could mean rethinking downsizing the house or delaying retirement.
Switching Careers or Serving Twice
Firefighting isn’t always a straight path. Some folks start in the private sector and then answer the call to serve their community mid-career. Others retire from the fire service and start a new career elsewhere. Under WEP, if you split your working years between a Social Security-covered job and a non-covered job (like many fire department roles), you got penalized on the Social Security end. We’ve heard from clients who worked a regular job for 15 years, then spent another 20 years as firefighters – only to have WEP cut down the Social Security they earned in those first 15 years.
The Spousal Benefit “Gotcha”:
Firefighters often have working spouses, and many counted on spousal or survivor Social Security benefits as part of their family retirement picture. GPO turned that picture upside down. For example, a firefighter’s wife who spent her life as a teacher (another job often not covered by Social Security) might find she couldn’t get much of her late firefighter husband’s Social Security survivor benefit because she had her own small teacher’s pension. Or vice versa: a firefighter with a pension could be denied a widower’s benefit based on his wife’s Social Security. Essentially, GPO often meant that the survivor of a firefighter got little or nothing from Social Security that their spouse paid in, precisely when they needed it most.
All in all, WEP and GPO created a sense that firefighters (and other public servants) were being treated as second-class citizens in the Social Security system. In fact, organizations like the International Association of Fire Fighters fought these policies for around 40 years on that very basis.
What Changes Now? (The Repeal and Its Effects)
You Get Your Full Social Security
If you’re a firefighter who earned Social Security benefits from other jobs, those benefits will no longer be subject to the WEP formula. In plain talk: Social Security will pay you the full amount you earned, period. The special penalty formula is gone. So if you were expecting, say, $800 a month from Social Security based on your side job income, you’ll get that full $800, not a dollar less.
Spousal and Survivor Benefits Restored
The repeal of GPO is a game-changer for many firefighter families. This means if your husband or wife paid into Social Security, you can claim the spousal or survivor benefits you’re entitled to without that 2/3 offset. For example, a retired firefighter can now receive a full spousal benefit based on their spouse’s Social Security, where before they might have gotten $0. Surviving spouses will no longer lose their widow(er)’s benefits because they have a firefighter’s pension. This adds a crucial safety net for families. It’s a huge sigh of relief knowing that if something happens to you or your spouse, the Social Security benefits will be there as expected, no offsets, no reductions.
Increases for Current Retirees
If you’re already retired and were affected by WEP or GPO, you should see an increase in your Social Security checks going forward. The law actually made the change effective for benefits payable beginning January 2024. That means the era of reduced checks is over. The Social Security Administration (SSA) is working out the details of adjusting payments.
In Conclusion
The repeal of WEP and GPO is a game-changer for your retirement. As a firefighter-focused firm, we’ve got your back– let’s incorporate your new Social Security benefits into your retirement plan. Contact Protection Red today to schedule your personalized retirement review – and make sure you’re making the most of this well-earned retirement. You’ve spent a career protecting others; now, let us help protect your financial future.
Sources:
